
PART 1 — THE PURPLE GUMMIES
The fifth time my five-year-old daughter fell asleep at the dinner table, her face landed right in a plate of spaghetti. As I wiped the sauce from her cheeks, she grabbed my wrist and whispered, “Mommy, don’t tell Dakota I told you. She gives us the sleepy bears so we won’t see her leave.”
I asked what she meant by sleepy bears. She said they were purple gummies from our babysitter’s purse, two for her and one for her little brother. Then she told me Dakota sometimes went away for a long time while they slept.
I worked in a pharmacy. I knew those gummies might contain something that didn’t belong in a small child’s body. But it was the second part of her confession that frightened me most.
Where was our babysitter going, and who was watching my children while she was gone?
My name is Florence Merritt, although most people call me Flo. I was thirty-eight then, raising two children on my own in Boise, Idaho. My daughter, Lark, was five, and my son, Isaac, whom everybody called Ike, had just turned three. I worked as a pharmacy technician at a neighborhood drugstore, usually from noon until eight in the evening.
I loved my job, but the hours made childcare difficult. My mother lived three hours away, and the licensed daycare centers near us either closed too early or cost more than I could manage. When a neighbor offered to recommend her daughter as a babysitter, I thought I’d finally caught a break.
Dakota Ellis was nineteen and lived three houses down. Her mother, Sheryl, was president of our neighborhood association, organized the annual block party, and seemed to know every family on our street. She spoke about Dakota as though the girl had never made a mistake in her life.
“She’s wonderful with children, Flo,” Sheryl told me. “And she’ll only charge fifteen dollars an hour. You won’t find anyone else willing to help you out like that.”
Dakota seemed responsible when we met. She asked about allergies, listened to the bedtime routine, and promised not to invite visitors over. For the first few weeks, she sent pictures of the children coloring, building blanket forts, and playing in the backyard.
Then September came, and something changed.
When I got home around eight-thirty, both children were usually asleep. Sometimes they were on the couch, still wearing their daytime clothes. Once, I found Ike curled up beneath the kitchen table with his toy fire truck beside him.
“They played hard today,” Dakota would explain while collecting her purse. “You know how little kids are. They just crash.”
Except mine didn’t.
On my days off, Lark could talk until ten at night, and Ike usually needed two bedtime stories before he’d settle down. I started noticing that they seemed especially tired on the evenings Dakota watched them.
Then Lark began falling asleep during dinner.
The first time, I assumed she was getting sick. The second time, I checked her temperature. By the fourth, I’d made an appointment with our pediatrician because I couldn’t explain why an otherwise energetic child was suddenly so drowsy.
The fifth time was the spaghetti.
After Lark told me about the gummies, I called Poison Control and the pediatrician’s after-hours service. They advised me to have both children evaluated promptly. I took them to the emergency department, where the medical staff monitored them and asked questions about possible exposure to medication or supplements.
Neither child needed intensive treatment, thankfully, but Ike was unusually difficult to wake. The physician explained that the exact substance couldn’t be identified from Lark’s description alone.
“Until you know what they’ve been given, don’t leave them with that caregiver again,” he said.
I assured him I wouldn’t.
That night, I sat between my children’s beds until nearly morning. Every time Ike shifted beneath his blanket, I leaned forward to make sure he was comfortable. I kept hearing Lark’s small voice asking me not to tell Dakota.
The following morning, I called my mother and asked whether she could stay with us for a few days. Then I walked down the street to speak with Sheryl.
She answered the door in her bathrobe, holding a coffee mug.
“Flo? Everything okay?”
“I need to ask you something about Dakota. Lark says she’s been giving the kids sleep gummies.”
Sheryl stared at me, then laughed.
“Oh, honey. Children make things up all the time.”
“Both kids were evaluated at the hospital last night. Lark described the gummies and said Dakota gives them out after lunch.”
Her smile disappeared.
“Are you seriously accusing my daughter of giving your children medication?”
“I’m asking whether you know anything about it.”
“Dakota’s practically raising those kids while you’re off working, and this is how you thank her?”
I felt my face grow hot.
“I pay your daughter to babysit, Sheryl. She’s not raising my children.”
“Well, somebody has to be there, doesn’t she?”
I looked at her for a moment, struggling to believe she’d actually said that.
“My children aren’t safe just because somebody’s supposed to be there. I need to know what’s happening in my house.”
Sheryl folded her arms.
“My daughter wouldn’t do anything to hurt those kids. And you’d better be careful about spreading accusations you can’t prove. People around here talk.”
I didn’t argue any further. There wasn’t much point in arguing with someone who’d already decided I was wrong.
I went home, documented everything Lark had told me, and contacted the police non-emergency line. An officer took my report and advised me to preserve the children’s medical records and any messages from Dakota.
I also told Dakota that I wouldn’t need her for the next several days. She replied with a cheerful message asking whether the children were feeling better.
I stared at that message for a long time.
Then I remembered the little security camera I’d bought after somebody took a package from my porch the previous winter.
It had been sitting in a drawer, unused. I installed it on the living room bookshelf, where it could see the couch and front entrance. I wasn’t going to put my children back in Dakota’s care to catch her doing something wrong, but I wanted the house monitored while my mother was helping.
As I connected the camera to my phone, I discovered that the app also contained recordings from an older front-door camera I’d installed months earlier.
That camera had been saving motion clips whenever somebody entered or left.
I opened the recordings.
The first showed Dakota leaving my house at 1:16 on a Thursday afternoon. She carried her purse, checked her reflection in the glass door, and walked toward the driveway.
She didn’t return until 5:42.
I checked the date against my work schedule.
I’d been at the pharmacy that entire afternoon.
Another recording showed her leaving at 1:08 and returning after five. A third showed nearly the same thing.
My hands began trembling as I wrote down the dates.
I kept opening clips, hoping there was some explanation I’d missed. Perhaps she’d taken the children to a playground. Perhaps they were with another responsible adult.
But the children never appeared beside her when she left.
Then I found a recording from the previous Tuesday.
At 1:10, Dakota walked out carrying her purse.
At 2:04, the door opened again.
This time, it was Lark.
She was barefoot, wearing her pink pajamas and holding her stuffed rabbit. She stood on the porch for several seconds before stepping onto the sidewalk.
Then she began walking toward Fairview Avenue, the busy four-lane road at the end of our street.
I watched the clip three times.
I remembered that afternoon. Dakota had mentioned that Lark wandered outside while she was using the bathroom, but said she’d brought her back immediately.
Now I knew that wasn’t true.
The camera showed nobody coming after my daughter.
I called Officer Bennett, the policeman who’d taken my report, and told him what I’d found. He arranged to collect the recordings and speak with our neighbors.
Before he arrived, I remembered something else.
Mr. Theodore Okerlund, an elderly man who lived in the yellow house on the corner, had mentioned seeing Lark outside that Tuesday. At the time, he’d simply told me she was a curious little girl who needed watching.
I hadn’t understood what he meant.
Now I did.
I walked to his house that afternoon.
Teddy Okerlund was eighty, a retired Navy mechanic who’d lived on our street for more than forty years. He usually sat on his porch wearing a red baseball cap, listening to baseball games on a little radio.
When I asked about that Tuesday, his expression changed.
“I was wondering when somebody might ask me about that,” he said.
He explained that he’d been watering his flowers when he noticed Lark walking alone toward Fairview.
“She didn’t have shoes on, Flo. And she was looking around like she was searching for somebody.”
“How close did she get to the road?”
He pointed toward the intersection.
“Close enough that I wasn’t taking chances. I called her name and went after her.”
“Did she tell you why she was outside?”
Teddy nodded.
“She said Dakota had gone to see somebody. Said she was looking for her.”
My throat tightened.
“And what happened after that?”
“I brought her back to your porch and stayed with her. Eventually, Dakota came home. She said she’d only stepped away for a minute.”
He looked down at his hands.
“I should’ve called you, Flo. I figured maybe I’d misunderstood the situation.”
“You stayed with my daughter until someone came back. That’s what matters.”
He shook his head.
“No child that little ought to be walking toward Fairview alone.”
I thanked him and asked whether he’d speak with Officer Bennett. He agreed immediately.