Fans are buzzing about a hidden detail in Selena Gomez’s engagement ring, leading to brutal comparisons with the rock worn by her rumored rival, Hailey Bieber.

On Wednesday evening, Gomez announced her engagement to boyfriend Benny Blanco, who proposed with a stunning marquise-shaped diamond ring paired with a matching band. The proposal featured a casual picnic complete with Taco Bell.

“Forever begins now,” Gomez captioned her Instagram post, sharing a series of heartwarming snapshots from the day.

However, eagle-eyed fans quickly turned their attention to Gomez’s ring, sparking online discussions and comparisons to Hailey Bieber’s engagement ring. The two women have long been rumored to be at odds, particularly due to Bieber’s marriage to Gomez’s ex, Justin Bieber.

On X, users speculated endlessly about the cost of each ring, fueling the ongoing tension between the two stars’ fan bases.

“Initial reports are confirming that the engagement ring Justin Bieber purchased for Hailey Bieber costs four times as much as the one Benny Blanco bought for Selena Gomez,” one user claimed, sharing images of both rings. Bieber’s ring is estimated at $265,000, while Gomez’s is reportedly valued at $70,000.

Supporters of Gomez defended the simplicity of her ring. “Selena doesn’t need overpriced gifts to feel important, unlike Hailey, whose husband had to go into debt for her ring,” one fan wrote. Another added, “Benny did in one year of dating what Justin couldn’t do in nearly 10 years.”

Others preferred Gomez’s ring for its understated elegance. “Selena’s looks better—it’s the perfect size. Hailey’s is just too big,” one person commented.

Still, there were those who favored Hailey’s sparkler, with one user noting, “Justin Bieber is Justin Bieber. I don’t even know who Benny Blanco is, but he’s definitely not on Justin’s level.”